Search blog.co.uk

Posts archive for: October, 2008
  • Have patience! India is different from US

    Many American companies especially banks and other finance companies have either failed or are at the verge of failure. Now the impact of this financial crisis is spreading to European and Asian countries also. Governments of US and European countries have already announced bail packages to save their sinking economies. This crisis of US has alarmed central banks all around the world. Even Reserve Bank of India has announced various measures including drastic reduction in CRR. Share Markets all around the world are under turmoil.

    In these circumstances Indian share market is also under severe stress. Panic selling in the share markets is pushing them to the bottom. But we must understand that there is a marked difference between Indian economy and economies of US and Europe. If we take a minute look at this crisis, we find that it started with sub-prime crisis in US. It happened like this that US banks gave loans at a large scale, without giving due consideration to the repaying capacity of the borrowers. It is well known with regard to credit card based US economy that American people spend more than their incomes. Inability of the American people to repay their loans led to large scale acquisition of their houses by the banks. Sale of these acquired houses by banks resulted in steep fall in the property prices. US banks increased heavy losses due to their inability to recover their loans. Another cause of heavy loss by these banks was due to their excessive involvement in forward trading. According to a rough estimate, hedge funds had put in 13 trillion US dollars in forward trading of crude oil. Initially price of crude oil jumped to around 150 US dollars per barrel but ultimately tumbled to near 80 US dollars per barrel, thanks to sharp reduction in demand for crude oil from US and European countries and increase in production by OPEC countries. This factor has also contributed to the crisis of US and European financial institutions. Lehman Brothers, who used to ‘educate’ the world about how to make investments have applied for bankruptcy and condition of many other financial institution is no better.

    Condition of India in this context is much different and much better. Loan are given by Indian banks on solid basis. Though its correct that some times Indian banks also indulge in unsafe lending. Such kind of loans, repayment of which is irregular are defined as Non Performing Assets (NPAs). These NPAs normally don’t exceed more than 5 to 7 percent of total loans by these banks. These NPAs are also not completely bad debts. Indian banks never lend like US banks. Sometimes Indians banks face the criticism that they undertake too much of paper work. But Indian banks don’t lend without a solid collateral. Apart from this Indian banks have to keep a major portion of their deposits with Reserve Bank of India in the form of cash reserves or have to invested in government securities as per the directions of RBI. Thus these banks have very little to spare for even lending. Being under the control of the government, these banks make minimum involvement in forward trading. It is natural that due to government control the public sectors banks are not able to earn heavy profits but at the same time there is no threat to their stability.

    In the last do decades some private banks have also come up in India. These banks do lend more than their capacity and even take risk involving themselves in forward trading. Some of these banks have definitely burned their hands in this American crisis and have lost a few thousand crores of rupees in the process. Rumors are on regarding probable failure of these banks. But we must keep in mind that these banks also function under the rules framed by RBI. According to these rules they have to invest heavily in government securities and keep a sizeable portion of their assets with RBI in the form of cash reserves. Even home loans given by these banks are also on solid footings. Thus in the present circumstances there is no dangers to these banks also. Thus we can say that there is no danger of failure of any Indian bank.

    Indian industry is also growing at fast pace, thanks to strong domestic demand. Despite all these problems Indian economy is all set to grow between 7 to 8 percent in the current financial year. Any turmoil in the share markets is not due to any problem within Indian economy. It is all because of large scale outflow of funds by Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs). These FIIs are indulging in panic selling in share markets. In the process they are purchasing dollars from RBI and transferring these dollars to their home countries. This is leading to sudden shortage of liquidity in Indian markets. Due to sudden increase in the demand for dollars value of rupee is also going down. But this problem is only for short term.

    For the last two decades our policy makers had been teaching the benefits of ‘integrating’ with the rest of the world. It was being told that the whole universe is like a village and therefore we should increase our economic relations with the rest of the world. But these people only are now proudly saying that Indian economy is ‘insulated’ from the rest of the world and therefore world recession is not going to affect our economy in any major way. Recent events have sufficiently proved that there should not be any blind integration with the rest of the world. We should have economic relations with the rest of the world only to the extent that our interests are not harmed in the process. Everything what glitters is not gold has been amply proved by the sudden collapse of US financial system. Those who try to sell the dreams of making India, US or Europe should now realize that the need of the hour is to build new India keeping in view the Indian capacities, resources, opportunities and problems.

    The time is not good for investors in the share markets. But there is no need to panic as well. Investors will have to keep patience. It would be better if they wait till settling of the dust of international turmoil.

  • Villain of Farmers' Suicides

    Villain of Farmers’ Suicides

    Dr. Ashwani Mahajan

    Menace of farmers’ suicides has turned into a calamity in the last two decades. For obvious reasons government tries to underestimate the number. But according to a rough estimate more than one lakh farmers have committed suicide so far. News of farmers’ suicides comes from all over the country but situation in Vidarbha has taken the form of an epidemic and on an average 3 farmers commit suicide per day. According to government records between January 2001 and November 2005, 3715 farmers had committed suicide. So far government has constituted 7 committees and panels to study about the problems and recommend remedial measures. Apart from the committees and panels constituted by the government, 46 universities and other institutes have also submitted their reports about the causes and remedies of the menace.

    Counts of Vidarbha suicides

    It is understandable that the government tries to save itself from bad name by underestimating crimes like theft, burglary, murders etc. They do the same for underestimating farmers’ suicides too. Although between 2001 and 2006, suicide toll was 15980 in 6 districts of Vidarbha but the government recognised only 1290 suicides as farmers’ suicides. Government is authorised to recognise or otherwise, a suicide as farmers suicide. This act of government underestimating the farmers’ suicides deprives the affected families from the relief amount distributed by the government machinery.

    Studies made under pressure

    It seems from the events that but for court intervention government had no interest in instituting enquiries or studies to look into the issue of farmers’ suicides. At first, Bombay High Court pulled the government of Maharashtra and as a result it asked Tata Institute of Social studies to submit a report on the issue. Institute did submit the report but nothing was heard from the government after that. Later Indira Gandhi Institute of Development Studies was entrusted with the similar job but perhaps its report again was left to eat dust on the shelves. In October 2005, Prime Minister asked Chairman of National Farmers Commission Dr. M.S. Swaminathan to visit Vidarbha and submit a report .But this exercise also met the fate of earlier reports. In March 2006, Planning Committee constituted a team under the chairmanship of Adarsh Mishra which submitted its report with no action taken again.

    In view of this hush-bush exercise, Bombay High Court directed Government of Maharashtra to undertake a comprehensive survey. Survey was undertaken covering 8560 villages and 20 lakh farmer families. The report revealed that 2 million farmers are under strain and another 4 million are under deep distress.

    After these revelations Prime Minister visited Vidarbha during June-July 2006 and released Rupees 3750 crores of relief amount but the farmers’ suicides continued unabated. Government of Maharashtra constituted yet another committee to put salt on the wounds. Government sources claim that waiving off of farmers’ loan by the government, as announced in the Union Budget 2008-09, would help check the problem. But experts opine that this is not going to serve the purpose as farmers committing suicides are mostly those who have borrowed from unorganised sources.

    Farmer’s indebtedness

    It is obvious that one commits suicide under deep distress. This distress stems from crop failure and inability to repay the loan already taken and also the inability to get their family members treated in wake of serious illness. This point is clear from the reports of various committees and panels constituted for this purpose. According to 59th Round of National Sample Survey Organisations (NSSO) data, major cause of farmers’ indebtedness is loan taken for farm related expenditure (60%) and loan taken for the treatment of their family members (20%). Aftermath of extensive Survey due to court’s intervention when S.K. Goel , Commissioner of Amravati , revealed that 20 lakh farmers are under stain and 40 lakh under deep distress, he was very obviously transferred.

    Root cause of the problem

    This is amply clear that a farmer commits suicide due to his inability to repay his loans. Crop failure accentuates this problem. But the question is why Vidarbha farmers were not committing suicide earlier. If we go deep into this we find that Vidarbha land is most suitable for cotton farming. Earlier farmers used to earn heavily from cotton farming. Data shows that one quintal of cotton was equivalent to 12 grams of gold 20 years back. A Farmer used to grow food grains just for self consumption and by selling cotton; he used to add to his riches. Cotton used to be called white gold. Today he gets merely rupees 1750 per quintal of cotton and in the last 10 years, prices of fertilizers, pesticides and other agricultural inputs have multiplied by 4 to 6 times.

    Why cotton prices didn’t increase along with the cost of production? Reason is simple, international price of cotton has declined from $ 1.10 in 1994 to nearly 50 cents now. Government of India reduced import duty on cotton to just 10% under pressure from WTO. How come cotton has become so cheap in international market? Whereas cost of cotton growing is around US$ 1.70 per kilogram in America and a farmer gets subsidy from the government to the extent of US$1.5 to 2.0 per kilogram. Due to this heavy subsidy U.S. farmers are able to export cotton at a much lower price; this is the root cause of Vidarbha farmers’ devastation.

    This problem is not limited to Vidarbha only. Farmers from all over the country especially Andhra Pradesh, Punjab, Uttar Pradesh are also committing suicides. Constantly rising input cost and non-remunerative prices compel them to end their lives. Again farmers’ devastation is not limited to India, farmers of most of the developing countries are getting ruined due to heavy subsidies being given by U.S. and some other developed countries. This is one of the basic reasons why Agreement on Agriculture (AOA) could not be finalised in WTO. Some cotton growing African countries are opposing any new WTO agreements tooth and nail.

    Government has to understand that foreign trade can not to be more important than farmers’ lives. In fact security of the farmer can only ensure prosperity.

Email subscription

You can receive the posts of this blog by email.

Tags
Calendar
<< < October 2008 > >>
Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa Su
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31
RSS Feed
RSS 1.0
Posts
Comments
RSS 2.0
Posts
Comments
Atom
Posts
Comments
Friends (0)

The friend list is empty.

Footer:

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.